What Makes a Great Trolling Motor for Musky Fishing?

What Makes a Great Trolling Motor for Musky Fishing?

Jodie Paul February 17, 2025

As angling goes, musky fishing can be one of the most challenging in terms of the ratio of catch to loss, so it makes sense to prepare for the musky season by navigating the right equipment to make your “on the water” experience as relaxed as possible. A reliable trolling motor is one of the most essential pieces of gear for musky anglers. Trolling motors can make all the difference between a successful day on the water and a frustrating one. Many qualities make the difference when seeking out the best trolling motor. Here are some key factors that make a trolling motor ideal for musky fishing:

Power and Thrust

Muskies are known for their powerful runs and can be found in various water conditions, from multi-lake-long waterways to 100000 acres of bolder-filled behemoths. A trolling motor with sufficient power and thrust is crucial to handle these big fish and navigate superbly different environments. Those who don’t venture out beyond their smaller sub-500-acre home lakes will be safe with 55 lbs, but for anglers seeking bigger waters, thrusts over 80 lbs are a must when dealing with wind and currents.

Quiet Operation

As muskies go, a little noise is expected, but updating to modern trolling motors can be a game changer as they glide with ease and silence in any scenario. A trolling motor with quiet operation is essential to avoid alerting these elusive fish to your presence. Brushless motors are known for their whisper-quiet performance, making them an excellent choice for musky fishing. Also, take care to keep an intact and smooth prop.  Chipped and rough edges to your prop can give low levels of added noise.  Prolong the life of a chipped prop by straightening edges with a file for smooth water-cutting action.

GPS and Spot-Lock Capabilities

Advanced features like GPS and Spot-Lock can be game-changers for musky anglers. GPS allows you to mark and return to productive fishing spots, while Spot-Lock anchors your boat in place with pinpoint accuracy, freeing you to focus on fishing rather than boat control. These features are handy when fishing in areas with strong currents or wind.  As always, musky fishing is a sport that really depends on developing repeatable patterns, so fishing without these features is not recommended as you advance.

Durability and Build Quality

Musky fishing often takes place in challenging environments, so a trolling motor must be built to withstand harsh conditions. Look for motors made from high-quality materials and with a reputation for durability. Stainless steel and composite materials are excellent choices for ensuring your motor can handle the rigors of musky fishing.  It goes without saying that if you experience issues within the first season of using your motor, then the issues will persist.  Don’t settle for a lemon.  Make sure you have a build quality that can be trusted.

Battery Life and Efficiency

Long days on the water require a trolling motor with efficient power consumption and long battery life. Look for motors with advanced battery management systems and energy-efficient designs to maximize your time on the water. Lithium-ion batteries are a popular choice for their lightweight, long-lasting performance.  A high-quality charging bank is highly recommended to keep on top of your batteries.  Using old pigtail chargers for batteries is a thing of the past.  Low and slow charges with a multi-bank system will keep your batteries in top performance condition.  

Ease of Use and Control

A great trolling motor should be easy to operate and offer precise control. Features like wireless remote control, foot pedal options, and intuitive interfaces make maneuvering your boat and adjusting settings on the fly easier. Consider motors with these user-friendly features to enhance your fishing experience.  As trolling motors improve, so do their features.  Wireless remotes are no longer a thing of the future.  They make directional control easy and spot lock on point.  But remember, upgraded features have a learning curve, so launch with the expectation of upgrading your brain's wiring when you upgrade your motor.

Choosing the right trolling motor for musky fishing can significantly impact your success on the water. Look for motors that offer power, quiet operation, advanced features, durability, and ease of use. It can’t be said enough that fishing becomes exceptionally more enjoyable and controlled with the right tools in place. With the right trolling motor, you'll be well-equipped to tackle the challenges of musky fishing and increase your chances of landing that trophy fish.